Inflating the tires, not reinventing the wheel ®

 

  • Home

  • Focused Instruction

  • Services

  • Resources

  • About Us

  • Blog

  • Contact us

  • Blog

  • More

    TESS

    Total Education Systems Support

    Providing Teachers Feedback in the Art and Science of Instruction

    April 21, 2015

    |

    Gene Tavernetti

     

    Recently I watched a portion of an interview of Nanci Atwell, the teacher who won the Varkey Foundation’s $1 million prize as the Global Teacher of the Year. The teacher was asked what advice she would give young people who wanted to enter the teaching profession.  The teacher said she would try to dissuade them from entering the profession.  Her reasoning was that Common Core Standards and all the assessments and high stake testing was taking all the creativity and teacher judgment out of the profession. Atwell further explained that teachers were being turned into “technicians,” making it hard for them to teach the best they knew how.

     

    My first reaction was how wrong she was!  Standards do not dictate how to teach.  Standards describe what we want students to learn.  Assessments do not dictate how to teach.  Assessments provide information about the manner in which students need to know something in order to achieve the targets.  What in the world was this obviously experienced and respected teacher talking about?  How was creativity being taken away from teachers?

     

    How could one of us be so wrong?  

     

    Then I had an opportunity to work with what I would describe as a strong, caring, and experienced teaching staff at an elementary school. This particular school had been designated Title 1 due to high poverty rates and Program Improvement under the NCLB.  The school also has a large number of students designated English Learners. 

     

    As a result of those designations the staff had been targeted to receive continuous and varied trainings aimed at improving isolated components of their instructional program.  Classroom visitations followed trainings by various “observers/coaches” to provide feedback on how the programs were being implemented.

     

    What was the feedback to teachers regarding English Language Development implementation?  “You are doing it wrong!”  

     

    What was the feedback regarding the new math program implementation? “You are doing it wrong!”

     

    As I worked with the staff it became obvious many teachers were much more guarded than other teachers I have coached. The staff reminded me of victims of abuse.  Many were lacking confidence. Many were defensive.  Many were expecting to be told once again, “You are doing it wrong!” 

     

    Because of past poor practices by prior ineffective coaches/consultants, both in-house and independent, the teachers had an extra layer of well-placed skepticism about our work together.

     

    I realized that Nanci Atwell, the award-winning teacher was right. Ineffective technical support around a narrow topic can manifest as nonsensical, shortsighted feedback to teachers. Coaches, consultants, and/or administrators who think their job is to judge instruction as right or wrong are making Ms. Atwell’s case.

     

    But, I was also right, it does not have to be that way.  There is an established body of science and research that applies to teaching.  When blended with the art of teaching, judgments such as right or wrong become nonsensical.  The science and art of teaching produces results that are on a continuum of least effective to most effective – not right or wrong. 

     

    Every teacher whom I have coached has appreciated feedback that will help him or her become more effective. 

    That being said there is a wrong way to coach teachers. Coaching that produces guarded, defensive teachers is counterproductive and just plain wrong.

     

    Districts need to make sure that the people who are “supporting” teachers actually have a record of positive results in encouraging greater effectiveness in both the art and science of teaching.

     

    This is why when we work with teachers, our feedback is on the effective things they are already doing and how they could be made even more effective and efficient. Our planning sessions, observations and debrief times are focused and intentional. We strive to honor the work of teachers by lightening their load, not heaping more onto it. We work, for the Ms. Atwells in classrooms everywhere, to support the creativity and teacher judgement that produce results for students.

    Tags:

    what are we doing to ourselves?

    Teacher Support

    feedback

    Morale

    Professional Development

    Please reload

    RSS Feed
    Join Our Newsletter
    Subscribe to Our Newsletter
    Featured Posts

    "But, where should we start?"

    December 6, 2016

    Multiple Initiatives, Multiple Rabbits Leave You Disappointed

    September 2, 2015

    "Who says? Compared to what?"

    February 1, 2017

    1/10
    Please reload

    Recent Posts

    Simple rules save lives and student motivation

    February 24, 2017

    "Who says? Compared to what?"

    February 1, 2017

    A simple idea, elegant execution

    January 17, 2017

    Why Students Achievement is Not Soaring: A Shocking Secret

    January 11, 2017

    "But, where should we start?"

    December 6, 2016

    Sorry, Not Sorry

    November 29, 2016

    Who said this was a good idea?

    October 25, 2016

    The order makes a difference, for words and for school improvement

    September 9, 2016

    Students avoiding the task? The solution might be smaller chunks

    August 17, 2016

    This too shall pass, be it muscle soreness or stress

    August 1, 2016

    Please reload

    Archive

    February 2017 (2)

    January 2017 (2)

    December 2016 (1)

    November 2016 (1)

    October 2016 (1)

    September 2016 (1)

    August 2016 (2)

    July 2016 (1)

    June 2016 (3)

    May 2016 (4)

    April 2016 (2)

    March 2016 (4)

    February 2016 (2)

    January 2016 (1)

    December 2015 (2)

    October 2015 (3)

    September 2015 (2)

    August 2015 (2)

    June 2015 (1)

    May 2015 (4)

    April 2015 (4)

    March 2015 (1)

    February 2015 (3)

    January 2015 (2)

    November 2014 (2)

    October 2014 (2)

    September 2014 (3)

    August 2014 (2)

    Please reload

    Search By Tags

    10000 hour rule

    15%

    21st century

    BOB time

    CCSS proficiencies

    Celebrate

    Choice Theory

    Dr. William Glasser

    Grit

    January to January

    Morale

    OWL time

    Professional Development

    Reflection

    SDC

    Symptoms

    TOTS

    Teacher Support

    Trainer of Trainers

    accountability

    accountability data

    analysis

    application

    art of teaching

    balanced approach

    be a student

    bike whisperer

    boss of the book

    buzz

    buzz words

    check for understanding

    chunking

    clarity

    classroom hacks

    close reading

    cognitive load

    collaboration

    collaborative learning

    common core

    complex tasks

    concept development

    concept maps

    critical thinking

    curriculum

    data and research

    dialog

    differentiation

    direct instruction

    discipline

    educational research

    educationese

    effective instruction

    enjoy the ride

    evaluate the research

    expensive purchase

    expert

    expert tip

    feedback

    first grade

    first instruction

    focus

    focused application

    focused instruction

    growth mindset

    homework

    humility

    implementation fatigue

    improving

    independent practice

    inflating the tires

    initiatives

    inspiration

    instruction

    instructional framework

    instructional leadership

    key ideas

    kwl

    language frame

    leadership

    leading with vision

    learning

    less is more

    lesson plan

    lesson steps

    lesson videos

    manageable chunks

    manipulatives

    meta-cognition

    modeling

    neomania

    new assessment

    new curriculum

    new name

    notes from the field

    parents

    planning

    planning tools

    prescription for success

    problem solving

    prob